Local Services Ads vs. Google Ads for contractors
Both put you above the free results, but they work very differently. Here's how to decide which one, if either, fits your business.
By the TableTurnerr team · · 7 min read
Short version: Local Services Ads charge per lead and lean heavily on your reviews and verification. Google Search Ads charge per click and give you more control but need more management. Neither replaces a strong Google Business Profile, because the free map pack shows on nearly every home-service search.
How Local Services Ads work
Local Services Ads (LSA) show at the very top of many home-service searches, often with a Google Guaranteed or Google Screened badge. You go through business verification and background checks, set your service area, job types and weekly budget, and pay when a customer contacts you through the ad, rather than per click. You can dispute leads that weren't valid, within Google's rules.
Your reviews and responsiveness strongly affect how often you show. Businesses with more reviews, a good rating and fast answers tend to do better.
How Google Search Ads work
Search Ads show below LSA and above the map pack. You choose keywords, write ads, send people to a page you control and pay each time someone clicks, whether or not they call. They give you more control over which jobs you target and where traffic lands, but they need careful management: negative keywords, call tracking and good landing pages.
Side by side
| Local Services Ads | Google Search Ads | |
|---|---|---|
| You pay for | Leads (calls, messages, bookings) | Clicks |
| Setup | Verification, background checks, licenses where required | Account, keywords, ads, landing pages |
| Control | Job types, area, budget | Keywords, ad copy, landing page, bids, schedule |
| Biggest factor | Reviews, responsiveness, verification | Ad quality, landing page, keyword choice |
| Management time | Lower | Higher |
Which should you choose?
- LSA often suits owner-operators and small teams in urgent trades (plumbing, HVAC, garage doors, locksmiths) who answer the phone fast and have solid reviews.
- Search Ads suit businesses that want specific high-value jobs (a full roof, a new HVAC system), have a good landing page and someone to manage the account.
- Neither may make sense yet if your Google profile is thin and reviews are few. Paid clicks to a weak profile convert poorly, and LSA rewards reviews anyway.
Where the free map pack fits
Ads stop when the budget stops. The map pack keeps working. Most contractors get the best return by fixing their profile and review flow first, then adding paid ads to fill gaps. See how to rank higher on Google Maps.
Part of our guides on local seo, websites & ads. Want it done for you? See Local SEO.